Hummingbird Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

Everyone has a repertoire. Even if cooking simply isn’t your thing or you pay a private chef to cook for you, everyone has a practiced dish up their sleeve. Whether it’s a spaghetti Bolognese, the Sunday roast, or a secret family recipe, it’s the dish you return to like a well-worn pair of slippers. Its comfort is quietly confidence-boosting and you’re soon bouncing around the kitchen, tea towel nonchalantly slung over one shoulder like the kitchen is your stage and you are the act cheered by thousands. All it takes is the knowledge it will be delicious and you are the next Gordon Ramsay.

That said, I experienced a sleepless night after baking my ‘signature dish’ – soft and squidgy Hummingbird cake – for my friend, Georgie’s, birthday. Georgie is my toughest critic; my Leiths comrade, private chef, culinary expert extraordinaire, and there I was baking her birthday cake. The pressure was too much. My vivid dreams included frenzied slicing of the cake before she even saw it (deep with self-destructive meaning) proving even the most practiced recipe, the paper sticky from cream cheese icing and spotted with grease, can give us doubts.

hummingbird cake

We all know these insecurities are meaningless. But it is good to know we all have them! Even the most confident chefs in Michelin-starred restaurants must feel a lurch in their stomach when cooking to impress, or simply for someone who knows the difference between hard-work and blagging it.

Why Hummingbird cake is utterly swoon-worthy

I discovered the delectable pleasures of Hummingbird cake a few years ago. As the recipient of a baking recipe book one Christmas I found Hummingbird cake nestled among its pages – banana and pineapple cake with a touch of cinnamon and coated in a thick layer of lemony cream cheese frosting. Warming from the spice yet fruity like a pina colada, it is dense, moist and tender, reminiscent of carrot cake or banana loaf. Even those adverse to banana find themselves cutting themselves a secretive second slice.

Hummingbird cake

Crowd-pleasing is this cake’s game. Popular with my family, even my dad who is one of those banana-sceptics, I expanded my audience to include my university housemates. It was my friend, Amber’s, birthday. The nine of us (yes, nine, and it was a small house too!) congregated around the coffee table and sang happy birthday in the flickering candle light, before she cut us large slabs of squidgy Hummingbird cake laden with creamy icing. Appreciative sounds of enjoyment and munching filled the room as one of my housemates exclaimed, ‘This is what cake should be!’ I would like to put that statement on my CV.

I then baked it in a loaf tin and packed it snugly in a plastic tub for tea and cake at Harriet’s. Nothing was better than tea and cake at Harriet’s. Her kitchen cabinets were decorated in reams of homemade bunting and we poured tea out of a teapot and drank from matching teacups she bought at a jumble sale. Chewing on a forkful of soft Hummingbird cake her eyes widened and she announced her surprise at its sweet flavour with the salty, tangy icing. We savoured every crumb, dabbing each up with the prongs of our forks.

hummingbird cake

And now, somehow subtly coerced into baking Georgie’s birthday cake (she has mystical powers of persuasion) I was both chuffed and daunted. I knew it was time to return to my repertoire and pulled out the old baking book. Hummingbird cake fit the bill; intriguingly fruity and never disappoints. But, how to impress a chef? Baked in my Bundt tin, the top had little room for fancy garnish. First the thick coating of cream cheese icing dripping down the side of the cake, then a sprinkling of salted pecan brittle and homemade dried pineapple flowers.

I needn’t have been worried. Georgie loved the cake and, although I sat there with baited breath hardly tasting the sponge, there was silence as we all tucked in, a few murmurs of surprise and an overall enthusiastic thumbs up.

hummingbird cake

So, the moral of this story, dear reader, is take to your kitchen and concoct your specialty dish, whether that be Hummingbird cake or not. Food you make with confidence and love is a comfort and will be enjoyed by all who eat it.

Hummingbird cake

Possibly my favourite cake of all time? It's that devilish combination of spice with pina colada and cream cheese frosting, who can really blame me?
If you'd like to make this cake as cupcakes with some coconut and passionfruit, try my Hummingbird cupcakes recipe!
Prep Time50 minutes
Cook Time1 hour
Course: Baking, Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: banana, cake, cream cheese, frosting, hummingbird, pineapple
Servings: 8
Author: Adapted from Commonsense Baking


For the cake

  • 2 ripe bananas mashed
  • 130 g tin of crushed pineapple definitely try to get hold of crushed pineapple, if you can't, blend pineapple rings in a food processor
  • 285 g sugar
  • 210 g self-raising flour
  • 1 tsp ground cinnamon
  • 1 tsp mixed spice
  • 170 ml flavourless oil sunflower, rapeseed etc.
  • 60 ml pineapple juice
  • 2 eggs

For the cream cheese frosting* (see notes)

  • 60 g unsalted butter softened
  • 135 g cream cheese softened
  • 185 g icing sugar
  • 1-2 tsp lemon juice


  • Preheat the oven to 180°C/350°F. Lightly grease a 20cm cake tin and line with baking parchment.
  • In a large bowl mix together the mashed banana, pineapple and sugar. Sift over the flour and spices then stir all together until combined.
  • In a separate bowl or jug whisk the wet ingredients – the oil, pineapple juice and eggs. Pour into the banana mixture and stir until smooth.
  • Pour the batter into the tin and bake for 1 hour or until a skewer inserted into the centre comes out clean, with a few tiny crumbs attached. Leave the cake in the tin for 15 minutes then turn out onto a cooling rack.
  • To make the frosting, beat together the butter and cream cheese until smooth. Sift in the icing sugar and gradually add splashes of lemon juice for the tangy flavour. Spread thickly over the cake once cool.


For the frosting: If you want the icing to drip down the sides of the cake then omit the butter and gradually add more lemon juice for a thick yet pourable consistency.
If you want to garnish the cake with some pretty pineapple flowers, take a look at this great guide by The Kitchn.

7 responses to “Hummingbird Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting”

  1. […] and indulgent than any sourdough I know. Banana cake is always top of my list – particularly the old chestnut Hummingbird cake – but for a vast cake it only requires two bananas; not helpful when you have fifteen at your […]

  2. Amanda Gregory-Haynes Avatar
    Amanda Gregory-Haynes

    Beautiful cake – turned out soooo well. Easy to make , light & crumbly !!

    1. Nigella Eats Everything Avatar

      Aw I’m so pleased! Hummingbird cake is just wonderful isn’t it! You’ve put a big smile on my face!

  3. Italian Goodness Avatar

    I’ve never paired pineapples and bananas in a recipe but I have to say it sounds very appealing and therefore very beautiful! I must try it!

    1. Nigella Eats Everything Avatar

      Aw thank you so much! I honestly have to say it’s one of my favourite cakes of all time, it’s so soft and moist, and I serve it to people who HATE banana and they don’t even notice that banana is a main ingredients haha

  4. […] colada, and coated in a thick layer of banana glace icing which cracked under my teeth. It was a Hummingbird cake in a […]

Leave a Reply